Forty-Fifth Annual

2006

University of Evansville


Officers

President: Laura Wertheimer, Cleveland State University
Vice-president: John Lomax, Ohio Northern University
Secretary: Louis Haas, Middle Tennessee State University
Treasurer: Martin Arbagi, Wright State University
Councilors: C. Matthew Phillips, Concordia University - Nebraska; Michael Lower, University of Minnesota
Program Director: Michael Lower, University of Minnesota
Local Arrangements:  Annette Parks, University of Evansville


Program

All meetings will be held in the Shanklin Theater in Hyde Hall

Friday, October 13

Noon - 6:00 p.m. Conference Registration Shanklin Theater Lobby

1:00-2:15 - Changing Views of the Crusades
Chair: C. Matthew Phillips, Concordia University

James L. Naus, Saint Louis University
"Group Identity in Twelfth-Century Crusade Narrative"

Timothy Smit, University of Minnesota
"Egypt as a Destination for Crusades in Relief of the Holy Land"

2:30-4:00 - Reconsiderations of Medieval Spirituality
Chair: June Mecham, University of Nebraska - Omaha

Greg Halfond, University of Minnesota
"Patrimoniolum Ecclesiae Nostrae: The Papal Estates in Merovingian Provence"

Daniel Patrick O'Dell, University of Nebraska - Omaha
"Christianizing Paganism or Paganizing Christianity?: Anglo-Saxon Charms and Religious Conversion"

Andrea Boffa, SUNY - Stony Brook
"'Sua socia specialissima et fideli amica:' St. Benevenuta and her Friends"

4:15-5:45 - From Old to New: Continuity and Discontinuity in Medieval England
Chair: Steven Stofferahn, Indiana State University

Andrew Grubb, University of Louisville
"The Holy Sepulchre Comes to England: Exploring the Peculiarly Medieval Legacy of an Early Christian Monument"

Andre Schmidt, Northwestern University
"From Old Testament to New: The Harrowing of Hell in the English Mystery Play Cycles"

Lindsey McNellis, University of Central Florida
"Burden of Proof: Changing Views of Sexual Violence in Medieval England"


Saturday, October 14

8:00 a.m. - noon Conference Registration Shanklin Theater Lobby

9:00-10:30 - Old Models and New Conceptions in the Early Middle Ages
Chair: Valerie L. Garver, Northern Illinois University

Jace Crouch, Oakland University
"Persecutors and Heretics, Patriarchs and Saints: Continuities and Discontinuities in the Historical Writings of Isidore of Seville"

Jonathan Couser, University of Notre Dame
"Christianity and Ideology in Early Medieval Bavaria"

Abigail Firey, University of Kentucky
"Roman or Christian? Legal procedure in the Carolingian Empire"

10:45-12:00 - Plenary Address
Chair: Annette Parks, University of Evansville

Frederick Suppe, Ball State University

12:15-2:15 Lunch and Business Meeting
Lower Union, Dunigan Hall

2:30-4:00 - Continuities and Discontinuities for the Medieval Aristocracy
Chair: Amy Livingstone, Wittenberg University

Jonathan R. Lyon, University of Chicago
"The Retirement of Aged Noblemen into their Monastic Foundations: Interpreting the Sources from Twelfth-Century Germany"

Ernest E. Jenkins, University of Kansas
"The Angevin Empire, Northern Iberia, and the Pyrenean Connection"

Linda E. Mitchell, Alfred University
"English, Irish, and In-Between: Discontinuities among Aristocratic Settlement Families in Ireland, 1218-1330"

4:15-5:30 - Developments in Institutions in Capetian France
Chair: Michael Ryan, Purdue University

Michael Bardot, Lincoln University
"Changes in Capetian Grain Management: Strategies of the Twelfth Century"

Adam J. Davis, Denison University
"Medieval Poor Hospitals and the Formation of a Charitable Society"


Meeting Minutes

While in Florence stolidly plowing my way through quaint and curious documents of forgotten lore, I stumbled across the entry "miscellaneous" in the finding aids for the Archivio di Stato Firenze Carte Strozziane. Feeling lucky, I placed my request. The next day bright and early-actually about 10:30 AM after the usual sustaining cappuccino, ciambelle, and bomboloni-I went into the depositorio with my request card and lo and behold a beaten up, dessicated, water stained, worm eaten leather-bound volume was presented to me-nothing on the outside to distinguish it. I returned to my seat and adjusted the 10 watt bulb. And turned the cover to the first page. There listed were the words, "Libro di debitori e creditori e ricordanze di Mezzo Ouest Conferenza di Storia di Mediavele MCMLXIII a MMVI". Oh, wonders of wonders, a libro segreto of an organization: perhaps a secret account book from some famous tower association; perhaps a family clan record of some infamous consorzeria; perhaps the accountings of a guild; perhaps details of all sorts of political machinations under the Medici. But anyhow, a ricordanze, that is remembrances-one of those uniquely Florentine diary-like account books which have provided us with so much of the political, business, and social history of the past. And this of the Midwest Medieval History Conference-their secret records and archive before my very eyes. Who or what was this group? I quivered with anticipation and turned the page. I would be looking at history face-to-face, fulfilling that noble dream of von Ranke.

Like most ricordanze this one began with a religious invocation, "al nome dell' onipotnete Idio e della Vergine madre maddona sancta Maria e della Clio." It then listed-again as usual-a litany of saintly patrons, powerful protectors of this organization as you could tell from the title given to them as Plenary: Paul Alexander, Gray C. Boyce, James Lea Cate, Robert S. Hoyt, Richard Sullvan, Gaines Post, Joshua Prawer, Joseph Strayer, Robert Lopez, Philippe Wolffe, Bernard Guenee, Giles Constable, John H. Mundy, Charles Davis, Bryce Lyon, Joseph Strayer-again-Peter Brown, Paul Meyvaert, Hans Eberhard Mayer, Richard Sullivan-again-David Herlihy, George Cuttino, Karl Morrison, John Baldwin, Robert Brentano, Sylvia Thrupp, C. Warren Hollister, Thomas Bisson, Robert Benson, John Baldwin-again-Donald Queller, Diane Owen Hughes, R. Dean War, Charles Bowlus, Richard Sullivan-again now thrice; all I can conclude is that he must have offered much long-time aid and comfort to this organization-Jerry Bentley, Elizabeth A. R. Brown, Walter Prevenier, Jo Ann McNamara, Paul Freedman, William Chester Jordan, Robert I Burns, James Powell, Andreas Winroth. A veritable library bookshelf of entries.

The entry continued, "questo libro ed di Saltato segretario"-which I liberally translate "as this book belongs to Skip-the secretary." Ahhhh, Saltato-a famous and renowned notary. This should be good. But no, as I turned the next page, the letters swarmed before my eyes moved and danced and combined and elided. My paleographical skills were of no avail-forgive me Frank Pegues, Jim Kittleson, and Don Queller; you tried I failed you-I pulled out the magnifying glass but no; I pulled out my little vade mecum, The elements of abbreviation in medieval Latin paleography by Adriano Cappelli, translated by David Heimann and Richard Kay. I stared real, real hard. But no-no luck; none of the paleographer's tools availed me. These reports were mysterious and cryptic-perhaps only for insiders. The notary/secretary's wit was beyond my comprehension. I tried but tired. Page after page after page.

Until at the end, for the last entry; the hand was different-an anonymous and obviously inferior hand; but my meager skills could read it. "Due mille e sei" 2006. So it began, "Richordanza e memoria che" that this conference was to have its next secret meeting in Evansville, Indiana, hosted by the University of Evansville, having been invited there by Professor Annette Parks, of that august institution. Evansville, a town I knew well, having been born and reared there. I got the sense though from these records that this conference must be very furtive and even feared as it seemed to move from place to place every year, unable to alight anywhere. Peripatetic-maybe even in exile perhaps the effects of some Guelph versus Ghibelline, neri o bianchi, factional struggle?

"Richordanze e memoria che" that Valerie Garver of Northern Illinois University ably prepared the program. On Friday October 13 under that typical ricordanze family heading "fanciulle di storici" children of the historians, three graduate student sessions were birthed-as listed under that quaint ricordanze phrase, "mi naqui." Changing Views of the Crusades chaired by Matt Phillips of Concordia University saw James Naus of Saint Louis University present "Group Identity in Twelfth-Century Crusade Narrative"; and Timothy Smit of the University of Minnesota presented "Egypt as a Destination for Crusades in Relief of the Holy Land." Reconsiderations of Medieval Sprituality chaired by June Mecham of the University of Nebraska-Omaha saw Greg Halfond of the University of Minnesota presented "Patrimoniolum ecclesiae nostrae: The Papal Estates in Merovingian Provence"; Daniel Patrick O'Dell of the University of Nebraska-Omaha presented "Christianizing Paganism or Paganizing Christianity? Anglo-Saxon Charms and Religious Conversion"; and Andrea Boffa of SUNY-Stony Brook present "'Sua socia specialissima er fideli amica': St. Benevenuta and Her Friends." And From Old to New: Continuity and Discontinuity in Medieval England chaired by Steve Stofferahn of Indiana State University saw Andrew Grubb of the University of Louisville present "The Holy Sepulchre Comes to England: Exploring the Peculiarly Medieval Legacy of an Early Christian Monument"; Andre Schmidt of Northwestern University presented "From Old Testament to New: The Harrowing of Hell in the English Mystery Play Cycles"; and Linsey McNellis of the University of Central Florida presented "Burden of Proof: Changing Views of Sexual Violence in Medieval England."

Richordanza e memoria che that this conferenza then adjourned to its pensione, il soggiorno di esecutivo, the Executive Inn, which doubly rack-rented me in a credit card mishap. So much for my returning home and welcome.

Richordanza e memoria che that after regrouping the conferenza formed into packs and descended upon osterie, taverne, ristorante, e trattorie. One group in particular headed on foot South to Madeleine's But dio it is located in Goosetown, the old Haynie's Corner-site of Evansville's notorious Red Light District during my childhood (or so I remember being told). What dangers lurk; what thrills exist-what sort of place is Madeleine's? The mind wonders and wanders. But no, just a fine fusion restaurant. And the area is gentrified. Change-the essence of history
And in typical ricordanze fashion, members of the conferenza who were being subsidized compiled detailed accountings of drinks, appetizers, drinks, salads and soup, drinks, main course (I had the Elk-rare as the chef advised), vino and drinks, desserts, drinks, and then after dinner drinks. Thus for the debitori part of this ricordanze account. Now for the creditori part. The credit to historians' memories
Richordanza e memoria che, that after a good nights slumber members of the conferenza returned to the McCurdy Alumni Memorial Union at the University of Evansville for the rest of the secret meeting. After a warm welcome, the morning session, Old Models and New Conceptions in the Early Middle Ages chaired by Valerie Garver of Northern Illinois University began. Jace Crouch of Oakland University failed to appear-assassinated, waylaid, kidnapped-I know not as the ricordanze is silent and this is not a lacuna. Jonathan Couser of the University of Notre Dame presented "Christianity and Ideology in Early Medieval Bavaria"; and Abigail Firey of the University of Kentucky presented "Roman or Christian? Legal Procedure in the Carolingian Empire."

Richordanza e memoria che that after a break the Plenary session, chaired by Annette Parks of the University of Evansville took place. Frederick Suppe of Ball State University presented "Anglo-Welsh Relations during the Twelfth Century: the Role of the Interpreter Families."

Richordanza e memoria che that after this the conferenza adjourned to the Atrium of the Koch Center for Engineering Science for lunch and for what the ricordanze describes as "la cosa nostra," this thing of ours, which I loosely translate as "business meeting." Ably presided over by President Laura Wertheimer a transfer of power occurred with John Lomax becoming president. Laura also ably aided this organization by compiling a "Golden Book" of sorts-an administrative memory to be passed down from president to president to president. To groans and yawns the Secretary delivered the minutes of the 44th Annual Conference. Martin Arbagi, Sacrae Largitatis Comes, loosely translated as "moneybags," delivered the treasurer's report, which included a report of substantial material in the black.
Richordanza e memoria che that the conference held elections: Matt Phillips elected vice-president/president elect; Linda Mitchell of Alfred University and Annette Parks elected councilors; Steve Stofferahn of Indiana State University elected as 2007 Program Chair; Haas and Arbagi continue. Discussion ensued over future venues-St. Louis for 2007, with Tom Madden hosting and possibly Dennison University for 2008-Kalamazoo panels for 2007; a reception at Kalamazoo for 2008; and the status and place of the sacred mailing list in an era of digitization, email, and text-messaging.

Richordanza e memoria che that after a short break, which allowed for some pleasant perambulating, the afternoon session began. Continuities and Discontinuities for the Medieval Aristocracy, chaired by Amy Livingstone of Wittenberg University, had Jonathan Lyon of the University of Chicago presenting "The Retirement of Aged Noblemen into their Monastic Foundations: Interpreting the Sources from Twelfth-Century Germany": Ernst Jenkins of the University o0f Kansas presenting "The Angevin Empire, Northern Iberia, and the Pyrenean Connection": and Linda Mitchell of Alfred University presenting "English, Irish, and In-Between: Discontinuities among Aristocratic Settlement families in Ireland, 1218-1330." Developments in Institutions in Capetian France chaired by Michael Ryan of Purdue University had Michael Bardot of Lincoln University presenting "Changes in Capetian Grain Management: Strategies of the Twelfth Century"; and Adam Davis of Denison University presenting "Medieval Poor Hospitals and the Formation of a Charitable Society."

Richordanza e memoria che that the conferenza then adjourned for a pleasant banquet at the Executive Inn, which was illustrated, enlivened, and illuminated by a display of medieval manuscripts from the collection of John Lawrence, a local businessman and philanthropist. Yours truly failed his paleography again here, when put to the test by Professor Powell. Lastly, the conference enjoyed the traditional president's reception and its libations.


Faithfully submitted by Louis Haas, Secretary


Archives       Main Page